This past weekend, I had an opportunity to visit my favorite comedy club (The Comedy Cellar in NYC) and had a blast (as usual).
Stand up comedians have always amazed me. The process of developing and refining a routine is fun to watch. If you've ever seen the movie "Comedian" about Jerry Seinfeld's return to stand-up, you know what I mean.
And the Comedy Cellar is a great place to witness it first-hand. It's a well-known club, so there are up-and-comers who have already gone out and tried their material out in smaller venues, but there is a good mix of big-name comedians who live close-by and may walk in to try out their new stuff.
The process reminds me of good email marketing practices. A comedian has to deliver value in the form of making his audience laugh. And a key to that is listening and incorporating the feedback that they're getting back.
One act on the bill the night I was there (Anthony Jeselnik) was preparing for the upcoming Comedy Central roast of Donald Trump. Toward the end of his routine, he ran through some of the jokes he's planning to use. At one point, after a big laugh, he stopped and made a note to himself, telling the crowd, "Maybe I need to open with that one." I won't give the joke away, but I will be watching and hoping he does.
A marketer who isn't paying attention to which mailing and/or links are generating the most inquiry, is missing an opportunity to improve their future sends.
A good comedian is clued into what is on people's minds. If you're still making jokes about Tiger Woods' affair, rather than, "Tiger's blood", you're not staying up-to-date (though I realize that my reference to Tiger's blood is probably already passe, which is one good reason for me to stick to my day job).
Making sure your emails are delivering new and desired information will keep your audience engaged and looking forward to your next email. If you continue to send the same old thing, without delivering value, you'll find your audience seeking out what they're looking for elsewhere.
Good comedians often ask questions. Whether they're targeted specifically at the front-row folks ("How long have you two been together?") or at the audience in general ("Anyone here from Europe?") they're an excellent way to get/keep the crowd engaged.
And the questions, while often targeted as a seguay to an already planned joke, can result in a new, fresh direction or new joke.
In email, this could be as simple as asking for more information at the time of sign-up, or regular surveys asking "How relevant was this article?". Treating your subscribers as one large, homogeneous group (or assuming that your audience hasn't changed over time) can mean missing out on great opportunities to connect, or sending information that is meaningless.
I also noticed that the other acts weren't cloistered away in sound-proof rooms while not performing. They're watching each other, seeing what works and what doesn't. They're picking up on how people are reacting to others and using that to help determine the direction of their own set. Is this topic going to be taboo? Does this crowd need more explanation or are they sharp? Marketers who aren't staying abreast of what others in their industry are doing can find their programs out-of-date. Sign up for competitors' mailings. Are they making use of video, or social sharing? If so, and you're not, you might want to step it up. Does your template still look like it did 5 years ago but the competition is fresh and slick? Check with our design team about creating a new one.
Timing and cadence are crucial to stand-up. Refining an act means figuring out when to give some time for the joke to sink in and when to circle back on a punchline. You want to figure out which jokes work together and in what order. Or even when what started as an unintended stammer broke the joke up in a newer, funnier version.
Do your mailings do better if sent on a specific day of the week? Does the time of day make a difference? Are you sending too often? Or do your subscribers want to hear from you more often? If you're not testing you could be off the mark.
If you want to do more, and are looking for help, let us know. We're here all week. And don't forget to tip your waitress.
Kris Dougherty | Director of Operations
PS: I mentioned the movie "Comedian" earlier, and it still has my all-time favorite trailer: http://www.imdb.com/video/screenplay/vi995033369/.